Top Voter Getter: Lou Gehrig
Final Results: October 23, 1999
Catchers
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Johnny Bench | 1,010,403 |
| 2. | Yogi Berra | 704,208 |
First Basemen
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Lou Gehrig | 1,207,992 |
| 2. | Mark McGwire | 517,992 |
Second Basemen
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Jackie Robinson | 788,116 |
| 2. | Rogers Hornsby | 630,761 |
Shortstop
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Cal Ripken, Jr. | 669, 033 |
| 2. | Ernie Banks | 598,168 |
| Honus Wagner* |
Third Basemen
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Mike Schmidt | 855,654 |
| 2. | Brooks Robinson | 761,700 |
Outfielders
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Babe Ruth | 1,158,044 |
| 2. | Hank Aaron | 1,156,782 |
| 3. | Ted Williams | 1,125,583 |
| 4. | Willie Mays | 1,115,896 |
| 5. | Joe DiMaggio | 1,054,423 |
| 6. | Mickey Mantle | 988,163 |
| 7. | Ty Cobb | 777,056 |
| 8. | Ken Griffey Jr. | 645,389 |
| 9. | Pete Rose | 629,742 |
| Stan Musial* |
Pitchers
| Rank | Player | Votes |
| 1. | Nolan Ryan | 992,040 |
| 2. | Sandy Kofax | 970,434 |
| 3. | Cy Young | 867,523 |
| 4. | Roger Clemens | 601,244 |
| 5. | Bob Gibson | 582,031 |
| 6. | Walter Johnson | 479,279 |
| Warren Spahn* | ||
| Lefty Grove* | ||
| Christy Mathewson* |
* Added to the team by a special panel.
Baseball's Greatest Moments
Here's the complete list of The Sporting News Baseball's 25 Greatest Moments from a few years ago.
1. The Shot Heard 'Round
the World
2. Bill Mazeroski's Home Run
3. Don Larsen's Perfect Game
4. Carlton Fisk Waves It Fair
5. Hank Aaron's 715th Home Run
6. Kirk Gibson's Home Run
7. Mark McGwire Hits No. 62
8. E-3 on Bill Buckner
9. Willie Mays' Catch
10. Enos Slaughter's Mad Dash
11. The Luckiest Man Alive Speech
12. Reggie Jackson's Three Homers
13. Willie McCovey Lines Out
14. Bucky Dent's Home Run
15. Roger Maris hits No. 61
16. Joe Carter's Home Run
17. Cal Ripken breaks Gehrig's Streak
18. Brooklyn wins the World Series
19. Haddix's Perfect Loss
20. Pete Rose gets hit No. 4,192
21. Chris Chambliss' Home Run
22. George Brett's Home Run
23. Owen and the Dropped Third Strike
24. Dave Henderson's Home Run
25. Cookie
Lavagetto beats Bill Bevens